@wadawabbit Dorie’s question is so important because everyone in America is going to face it at some point I thought it deserved its own topic.
Original Medicare costs more over your lifetime than most Medicare Advantage plans. The trade off is Medicare Advantage plans have more restrictions on coverage.
Medigap plans (aka supplement plans) cover much of the patient responsibility costs of Original Medicare. Things like the 20% Part B copay. See Compare Medigap Plan Benefits | Medicare for details. When you are a young a healthy 65, the premium for a medigap plan will probably exceed the services the plan is paying for. As you get older you’ll use more services that flip that value so paying for the medigap plan is less expensive than paying the copay. Medigap plans pay their part of any service that Medicare has already approved a claim for. There are limited times when you can buy a Medigap plan without medical underwriting. Buying a Medigap policy | Medicare Medical underwriting means the ability to buy a plan and the price depends on if you are healthy. Here’s an application for a Anthem California medigap plan as an example. For people with diabetes check out Section 2.
A few states have exceptions providing additional Medigap eligibility, check with a SHIP counselor for info.
This is a lot of good information, Chris @spdif , thanks for posting and getting the conversation moving. (BTW, the first link didn’t work for me. ) A point everyone must keep in mind is that MediGap plans as well as Medicare Advantage can differ significantly from place-to-place and state-to-state.
I didn’t begin using Medicare until 2010, five years after I should have enrolled at age 65, so I missed out on some options but did enroll in a UHC Medicare Advantage plan which I’m debating about keeping now for another year. About 10 years ago I tried to get an UHD MediGap plans and the company sales rep could not then demonstrate any savings and truthfully told me that with a Gap plan premium I’d pay might except benefits received. A multi-line private insurance agent reviewed my needs a few years ago and told me the same.
Right now, I’m considering if I might shift from my Advantage PPO to an available HMO UHC Medicare Advantage designed specifically for individuals having certain chronic conditions - diabetes, congestive heart disease, etc. There is a small additional premium I’d need to pay upfront, but the benefit for me is that specialist visits co-pay per visit is $30 less.